The Financial Gazette

  • Increase font size
  • Default font size
  • Decrease font size
Home Sport Killing soccer in Africa

Killing soccer in Africa

E-mail Print PDF

 Olukayode Thomas, Bisong Etahoben, Dumisani Ndlela, Eric Mwamba, Ken Opala, Phathisani Moyo & Charles Rukuni

AFRICA’S dismal performance at the 2010 World Cup — with the exception of Ghana — should be no surprise.

 
A FAIR investigation into soccer management in eight African countries — Camer-oon, Ghana, Cote d’Ivoire, Kenya, Nigeria, South Africa, Zambia and Zimbabwe, found that while players have sacrificed their personal fortunes to develop, not just soccer, but their own communities and have, in some cases, bailed out their national teams, the administrators tasked with developing the game focus on personal gain.
In Cameroon, traditionally Africa’s foremost soccer country, and the home of  Confederation of African Football (CAF) president, Issa Hayatou, soccer stadiums are empty.
“How do you want people to attend matches when their favourite players are not on the field?” asks Prince Ndoki Mukete, former assistant secretary-general of the Came-roonian football association (FECAFOOT).
The reasons for the absence of both supporters and the most famous players from the Cameroonian stadiums is simple, adds Mukete, “It’s transfers. Our soccer officials quickly sign deals for player transfers as soon as a player shows promise. Trans-fers bring in money.”
The effect of the focus on transfers is that every good player knows that his value is to the outside world and not to the national soccer team.
Samuel Eto’o, one of the best known players from Cameroon, and currently the most decorated African player, is only 29, but he has been in international soccer since he was 16, playing for top clubs like Real Madrid, Mallorca, Barcelona and Int-ernazionale. Other top players in Cameroon have similar histories. They often don’t perform well on the rare occasions that they are playing nationally, since getting hurt or exhausted will diminish their international value.
Mukete regrets the situation, which he says, has gotten out of hand recently: “We need to retain some value here. Soccer cannot develop when the stadiums are empty.”
Soccer development does not seem high on the agenda of the present FECAFOOT, which is a virtual top 10 of real estate owners, sports goods manufacturers’ agents, lawyers (who organise player transfers), transport and hotel contractors, and public relations agents. At any FECAFOOT meeting in Cameroon, businesspeople reportedly fight to get access to the rich spoils that have turned at least nine of the federations’ officials extremely wealthy.
Beefing up payment for FECAFOOT services is a common scourge, with a prime example, cited in pending court papers against four FECAFOOT officials in Cameroon, being a bill for an air-conditioned Prado for the Malawi team at the occasion of the African Cup of Nations in January 2010, when the actual vehicle offered to the Malawians was a dilapidated Toyota.
The court documents, which were obtained by FAIR, show that FECAFOOT vice-president, David May-ebi, receives regular payments from sports materials manufacturer, Puma, into his personal bank account, without reflecting the amounts in FECAFOOT records.
Co-bidder for the same sponsorship, Adidas, that did not offer a bribe, lost out. Other FECAFOOT documents seen by FAIR are player transfer contracts in which birth dates of players are altered to make them more easily marketable. Club origins of players are altered sometimes as well, so that the purported owners of the clubs can cash in on transfer fees. Some players sold off in this way have not made it in international soccer and live in poor conditions in countries such as Indonesia, China and Mexico. 
A recent state audit, likely prom-pted by revelations made by a government delegate to FECAFO-OT, Jean Lambert Nang, has recommended the prosecution of the four FECAFOOT officials charged in the court papers.
However, observers do not expect these prosecutions to take off. Said one such observer: “They can’t do that, bec-ause everybody is in on it.” 
Within all this, Cameroon’s players seem to be forgotten. When ne-ws reports said they had compla-ined about “poor payment” in the run-up to the Wor-ld Cup, soccer officials stated in resp-onse that the players were not “patr-iotic” enough. 
Cameroon was knocked out in the first round after losing all its three games against the Netherlands, Den-mark and Japan.
Being “unpatriotic” was also one of the epithets directed at a me-mber of the FAIR team in Came-roon, when he attempted to inve-stigate the sources of  Hayatou’s wea-lth. The reporter was threatened, beaten and has been in hiding since the incident earlier this year.
Partying in Cote d’Ivoire
Cote d’Ivoire — a country of extremely poor coffee and cocoa farmers — spends millions of US dollars on its soccer managers, with very little national performance in return. The coffee and cocoa industry is one of the soccer federation, Federation Ivoiri-enne de Football (FIF)’s principal sponsors, jostling for prime position with mobile telephone operator, Orange Cote d’Ivoire. Other major sponsors are the National Petroleum Operations Com-pany (PETROCI) and the Petroleum Stocks Manag-ement Company (GESTOCI).
Estimates of the amounts that are contributed by these major sponsors are not made public, but sources say they could be as high as US$40 million per year.
Sadly, Cote d’Ivoire has received very little national soccer performance in return. Though equipped with such great international stars as Didier Drogba, the team lacks cohesion and is mostly, like Cameroon, concerned about individual players’ performances outside their country. At the World Cup, Cote d’Ivoire was knocked out in the first round. 
Soccer officials and local government allies in this country, meanwhile, make money out of fraudulent ticket sales and building contracts that seldom materialise into the actual buildings as intended.
Abidjan stadium dates from 1945 and only has 35 000 seats. This is so small that, when extra tickets for non-existent seats were fraudulently sold at the World Cup qualifying match against Malawi in 2009, a stampede killed 20 people and injured another 135.
FIF has reported this particular incident as “an unfortunate experience” and refers to “funds allocated to the presidents of the clubs of Anyama, Korhogo and to the mayor of Bouaflé” for the refurbishment of their stadiums, which was apparently never carried out.
A number of low-level officials were fined for the fraudulent ticket sales leading up to the Abidjan stampede, but local award-winning journalist, André Silver Konan, who investigated the matter, has gone on record to say that only small fry got punished and that “big fish” were left alone.
(To be continued next week)

- FAIR investigative team: Olukayode Thomas, Biso-ng Etahoben, Dumisani Ndlela, Eric Mwamba, Ken Opala, Phathisani Moyo & Charles Rukuni.

 

Comments (46)Add Comment
...
written by Fake Oakley Sungla*ses, February 21, 2012
Great deals on h**p://w**.cheapoakleyssungla*sesoutlet.com/! Fascinating prices and saving up to 69%! It blended the art of h**p://w**.cheapoakleyssungla*sesoutlet.com/ with the science of precision ...DESXIAOXIN
...
written by Cde Made, January 08, 2012

COME ON GUYS : ***** Friday, 17 September 2010 09:35
...
written by Cheap clothing, December 28, 2011
Where you can buy Cheap clothing? Lisa**la.com is a big wholesaler who supply cheap clothing.The best material, the nice quality clothing. All clothing are the factories outlet. So you can get a cheap price .
...
written by Custom NFL Jerseys Wholesale, December 23, 2011
h**p://w**.topfashiontrade.com/
h**p://w**.shoes-hats-shop.com/
...
written by ralph lauren polo, November 22, 2011
wholesale and retail ralph lauren polosmilies/wink.gif
...
written by Canada Goose Parka, October 26, 2011
Your blog is very well, I hope can share m*re wonderful blog with you,and Welcome to h**p://w**.canadagoose-online.co.uk/
...
written by New Era Hats, October 06, 2011
New Era Hats h**p://w**.likehats.com has always been an essential supply for fashionable people, regardless of matched with what style of clothing, as long as you have the courage to try, there always will be a unique feel.
...
written by 传世私服, September 20, 2011
Vick, in his return to Atlanta h**p://w**.2csf.com/ as the Eagles' starting quarterback, pa*sed for 242 yards and two touchdowns and ran h**p://w**.ajiecs.com/ 25 yards on six carries.
...
written by Jack, September 13, 2011
Thanks
Kmart Locations
Kmart Store Locator
...
written by Moncler Online, September 10, 2011
Great post. I just stumbled upon your blog and wanted to say that I have really enjoyed browsing your blog posts about h**p://w**.monclerdownjacketsoutlet.com . In any case I’ll be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again soon for m*re informations on h**p://w**.monclerdownjacketsoutlet.com!
...
written by Burberry Outlet, September 09, 2011
Thank you for your great article and I enjoyed reading it keep the good work.
...
written by burberry outlet, August 23, 2011
Well, I am so excited that I have found this your post because I have been searching for some information about h**p://w**.burberry1856.net . Good post. I am taught one thing tougher on different blogs everyday and may you all can pay attention on h**p://w**.burberry1856.net.
...
written by mary , August 09, 2011
Dear friend, you need to have a n*ble temperament... Want to let oneself show m*re beautiful shape?Wear a different high heels to place a different personality
here you also like style name .discount... If male compatriots m*re should go to see the word may buy for the one you love. The m*re can show the beauty of the different w**.heelsvogue.com I think you could use a minute to our website... Can see let you the unexpected harvest! thank you
smilies/smiley.gif
...
written by w**.africvillemagazine.com, July 15, 2011
Sport is not taken seriously in Africa. While some administrators are to blame, the real problem lies with sport not being taken seriously. Soccer bodies lack the much needed resources. There is also a myth that if you hire a foreign coach then you will succeed. It goes beyond wasting money hiring foreign coaches and paying them top salaries. There are a lot of things that need to be changed for soccer to succeed in Africa.
w**.africvillemagazine.com
...
written by Mike Rollis, July 12, 2011
I feel fervently about this and I take pleasure in learning about this topic. I will surely inform you all once I make use of the code above. Good blog h**p://w**.prowordpress.net/
...
written by Supra TK Society , July 01, 2011
mother
Supra Skytop II, brothers, is a supra society make you worry。as an excuse to stall the meet Supra TK Society, I Room, peeped through the photos my father , my mother ’s picture. the photo and the woman , smiling flower Supra Strapped II, as it is and I have a face exactly the same as me and my mother . I am glad , as I have a mother ’s face Supra Thunder Hightop, At least my father could not bear to hurt to me.
I would not rely on Supra Shoes for sale, and sometimes even I make a suggestion on what . In the body, I felt a feeling never experienced . may be that you care deeply about this young lady Supra Vaider Shoes, Miss supra supra tk tells the truth to be horrid to you Women’s Supra Shoes. supra society smiled, I hold back supra supra tk, Supra Cuttler
you finally come back 。and the third is the main force ambushes a group from the completion of an engineering battalion deployed To them Supra Indy NS, and three thousand troops, should be , while the attack alone Supra Strapped NS,there are four groups Longyuan completed

...
written by h**p:/juicycoutures-outlets.com, June 17, 2011
Lasting in high quality materials, Burberry Bags are made upscale luxury suitable for women of all ages. Sophisticated design and cla*sic style Burberry Watches is welcomed by m*re and m*re advanced person. Burberry Canada is a right place for you to choose real Burberry.

h**p:/juicycoutures-outlets.com
...
written by Jordan Shoes Outlet, May 25, 2011
h**p://w**.burberryscarvessale.com/Burberry-Degrade-Frame-Sungla*ses-259
...
written by toshi888, May 20, 2011
h**p://sale-cheap-shoes.com is a B2C website for you to buy cheap nike dunk sb shoes. we sale cheap shoes nike kids shoes,cheap nike shoes,nike dunk sb shoes,50&#xof;f with free shipping
...
written by Coach Bags, May 09, 2011
Buy discount coach handbags and h**p://w**.coachbuying.com/coach-purses-c-7.html sale from h**p://w**.coachbuying.com store online,we offer elegant and fashion coach free shipping and fast delivery.Coach women's handbags were made out of sturdy cowhide, which was of much better quality than many other bags.
...
written by cheap air max shoes, May 08, 2011
h**p://nikeairmaxmall.com you trust online nike shoes,air jordan shoes store,buy air max 2010 h**p://nikeairmaxmall.com/ air max 2009 with cheap price,free shipping,good service. pay by paypal,credit card,western union or bank tranfer...
...
written by New Era Caps , April 26, 2011
Great. m*re dumbed-down, h**p://w**.new-era-hats.net/NFL-hat_124.html
h**p://w**.new-era-hats.net/DC-hat_100.htmlcondescending blather from people likely sticking their noses in the public feed trough. Gee, let's have the politicians put some all-knowing bureaucrats in charge to tell us what to do, and decide who should and should not be rich! I'm sure they will take care of us all then. Please help us, oh wise ones!
...
written by vibram five finger, April 23, 2011
h**p://w**.vibramfivefingersshoesusa.com
Do you ever know about the funny vibrams five fingers and what do the vibram five fingers looks like?Do you realize the making principle and function of vibram five finger shoes? Now I am very happy to talk about vibram five fingers shoes with all of you because I just know somewhat about five fingers vibram.The rubber sole of vibram fivefinger shoes are quite soft.You may feel strange when you wear vibram five fingers shoes at the first time.But you will feel very comfortable after you wear vibram fivefingers several time.Then you are supposed to know that vibram five fingers can protect our feet to a great degree.
...
written by jing123, April 11, 2011
h**p://w**.koopthoma*sabo.com/echte-thomas-sabo.html
...
written by Vuyiswa, April 03, 2011
Norman Mapeza is a novice when it comes to coaching our national team. The only good coaches we have here in Zimbabwe is Chidzabwa and Rahman . As long as we have Mapeza who ignores Honour Gombami and Esrom Nyandoro, we are going nowhere. He sould stop this thing of '' i am building the team'' We want to qualify not to build a team. The team is already there and there is no point of you building a team.

The best is for Mapeza to tell Sharuko, Kausiyo and Mabika that they should start campaigning for his exit.
...
written by BeautifulShoes, Sr., March 23, 2011
discount Alexander McQueen Pump shoesIf you have been conquered by Prada’s perspective for the season yet you are not exactly thrilled by wedges or heeled sandals you have other interesting choices as well. A checkered platform shoe with woven details or a hybrid between Oxford shoes and sneakers, in the form of flatforms, an interesting shoe trend for the next season are other exciting options. All in all, the Prada spring 2011 shoe collection is a definitely interesting one for those who are in a permanent search of style inspiration for the next season.
...
written by bere chikara fana, March 11, 2011
why dembare playing all charities pliz u must no that all teams need money,DEMBARE V CAPS,DEMBARE V HIGHLANDER & DEMBARE V BULLS HAZVISI GOOD
...
written by vibram five finger, March 09, 2011
...
written by avelino mazorodze, February 25, 2011
we do not want dictotors in football hayatou has stayed long in football adminstration now what he is after is his pocket and not football we need fresh brains people who are inovative other continents are doing well there is no african country that has reached the quoter final stage accept for one even when the continent is hosting the world cup, its a pitty.
...
written by Perry35Reba, February 18, 2011
I guess that to receive the credit loans from creditors you should have a firm reason. But, one time I've got a auto loan, because I wanted to buy a car.
...
written by hongyanzhen, February 16, 2011
http://www.skymigration.com/
http://www.skymigration.com/singaporeimmigration.html
...
written by Replica NFL jerseys, January 10, 2011
http://www.lovejerseys.com/nfl-jersey-c-65.html/
Among the many baseball players and available shirts, shirts, Derek Jeter and Alex Rodriguez are definitely the most popular and sold well in recent years. These two top-selling Replica NFL jerseys are the most duplicates. Remember to check out that there are no problems of legitimacy. As with any shirt other than a broker, check the MLB logo on the jersey, sewing properly, and other signs of replica jerseys.
...
written by h**p://w**.daunenjacke-moncler.com/, January 08, 2011
http://www.daunenjacke-moncler.com/
http://www.giubbottimoncler.org/
...
written by the Charm in Moncler, January 05, 2011
http://www.doudoune-moncler-france.com
welcome to our webside,there have best goods and best sevice,please click the title or name enterd.
...
written by sexy guiders, January 05, 2011
http://www.top-jordans.com/ oh ,fack !I never see so beautifull girl with shoes,Do you want to know m*re about her,please click here to enjoy
...
written by sexy girls, January 05, 2011
http://www.cheapaustraliaugg.com/ wow ,it's very sexy ,sex shopping ,i like it very much
i want to share it with all friends,please click it here quickly
...
written by mbt shoes sale, January 03, 2011
http://www.mbtpanda.com
http://www.mbtpanda.com
earth shoes
earth shoes outlet
exercise shoes
footwear for sale
footwear mbt
green shoes habari mbt
health shoes
kisumu mbt
m and m shoes
mbt
mbt boots
mbt buy
mbt casual
mbt chapa
mbt cheap
mbt cheap shoes
mbt clearance
mbt clearance shoes
mbt discount
mbt discount shoes
mbt ema
mbt footwear
mbt footwear sale
mbt for men
mbt for sale
mbt habari
mbt kimondo
mbt kisumu
mbt kisumu 2
mbt lami
mbt mbt shoes
mbt men
mbt mens
mbt mens shoes
mbt mwalk
mbt on sale
mbt review
mbt reviews
mbt
mbt sale
mbt sale shoes
mbt shoe
mbt shoes
mbt shoes cheap
mbt shoes cheapest
mbt shoes clearance
mbt shoes discount
mbt shoes discounted
mbt shoes discounts
mbt shoes for cheap
mbt shoes for men
mbt shoes for sale
mbt shoes men
mbt shoes mens
mbt shoes on clearance
mbt shoes on sale
...
written by werty, December 13, 2010
http://www.replica-handbags-outlets.com/
http://www.louis-vuitton-handbags-outlets.com/
...
written by rdytr, December 02, 2010
ugg nederland
goedkope ugg
ugg laarzen
ugg australia nederland
ugg store rotterdam
ugg schoenen
ugg kopen
ugg amsterdam
ugg bestellen
ugg online kopen
ugg online bestellen
kinder ugg
ugg goedkoop
ugg maten
ugg nl
ugg in nederland
nep ugg
echte ugg
goedkoopste ugg
ugg goedkoopste
ugg voor kids
maten ugg
online ugg bestellen
laarzen ugg
ugg amerika
uggs for cheap
ugg warmer schoenen
...
written by JK, November 11, 2010
Interesting post. There is a similarly interesting article here: http://jimmykainja.co.uk/afric...-continent’s-own-economy/
...
written by MMD, October 31, 2010
The beautiful game
...
written by cheap uggs, October 13, 2010
so good to have one
uggs outlet
cheap uggs
uggs 2010
...
written by zulu, October 04, 2010
Its a pitty that our football has gone down to the levels that brings disgrace to anyone a*sociated with football.We probably need a good wake-up call and start doing what we used to do-play football.The element of money has destroyed the most popular game in Africa.Noone seems to ralise that football is business and with any business you invest to get any dividends.Most clubs and agents just want to sale and sale without investing into it.As a good example of football business just look at how Manchester United did business last season.Bought Ronaldo for £12m and sold him for £80m after he helped them to win trophies and most importantly attracted m*re supporters for the club---good business.Look at Wenger,he buys a player make hin good and club benefits from player contribution and sells when player attracts m*re money for the club---Adebayor in mind. Till when Bosso ,Dimbare ,Makepekepe,and all clubs start to think along these lines we remain doomed.Its the local teams and that makes football great.Look at Spain,its Madrid and the likes of Baca that make spannish football not the national team.England last won world cup in 1966,but English football is made by the clubs.As for bad business just look at how South African clubs are run---now thats bad management even if they do have the money.The principle is LETS LOOK AT FOOTBALL AS A BUSINESS WHERE YOU INVEST AND THEN GET DIVIDENDS LATER.
...
written by Wurayayi Mponesi , October 02, 2010
So shameful are Robson Sharuko s double standards i dont believe he still strutts the streets of Harare with his head high. Sharuko, the appointment of Zimbabwe s national team coach has become so important to you yet you ignored the scandal on betting syndicates that has left our country s ratings at an all time low of 118. Mapeza was one of the coaches on those trips but suddenly he is your favourite choice. Sharuko also travelled with the warriors on SEVERAL trips to Asia and deliberately misinformed the nation about some heavy defeats thereby creating a respectable scoreline for the warriors where they had lost dismally. What was Sharuko s agenda. Where in the world do you get journalists who cook up scorelines for readers and still wake up the following m*rning to accuse their a*sociations of misconduct. How come Sharuko never criticised the coaches when they lost in Malaysia only to wake up and make noise when Seintfeit was appointed by ZIFA. We are not children and the fact that Sharuko s Herald can stroke his spoiled ego does not distract our discerning minds on the gist of the matter. SHARUKO IS A BIG SUSPECT OF THE BETTING SYNDICATES.
...
written by Robert, September 29, 2010
Brazil exports soccer players like no one's business, but they are still the best. We need to produce thousands of quality players period
...
written by Givalo, September 24, 2010
Whilst your observations were, in the main correct, the role of journalists in destroying African soccer should not be underestimated.

Take for instance Robson Sharuko's single handed attempt to force Norman Mapeza into the national team coaching structures. Can Norman Mapeza publish his coaching CV?

It's so shameful.

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security code
Write the displayed characters


busy